Ohio State vs Indiana Picks and Predictions for Saturday October 17 2026
The Ohio State Buckeyes visit the Indiana Hoosiers at Memorial Stadium in Bloomington, Indiana, on Saturday, October 17, 2026. Kickoff is scheduled for 12:00 PM ET, with national coverage on FOX. Ohio State enters following an impressive 45-16 victory over Maryland, while Indiana remains undefeated after rallying for a dramatic 20-17 victory against Nebraska. The matchup features two of the Big Ten’s strongest programs and gives Ohio State an opportunity to avenge last season’s narrow conference championship defeat. The Buckeyes are favored by 4.5 points in an October 11 market comparison, with the total set at 49.5 points. Be sure to check out our free college football picks for more predictions throughout the season.
Ohio State Buckeyes Have Been Dangerous Offensively
Ohio State enters Saturday at 5-1 overall following four consecutive victories since its narrow 24-23 defeat against Texas. The Buckeyes have responded with wins over Kent State, Illinois, Iowa, and Maryland, demonstrating considerable offensive production against different opponents. Saturday’s 45-16 victory over Maryland was particularly encouraging because Ohio State established control early and never allowed the Terrapins to seriously threaten. The Buckeyes have now scored at least 31 points during each game of their winning streak.
The offensive production has been impressive, particularly through the passing attack and improved rushing efficiency. Ohio State generated enough offense against Maryland to establish a comfortable advantage while limiting the Terrapins to just 64 passing yards and 82 rushing yards. That defensive performance was important because the Buckeyes have been most dangerous when their offense receives repeated opportunities following short opposing possessions. Ohio State also demonstrated the ability to establish its ground game against Maryland, providing a more balanced approach than opponents have occasionally seen earlier in the season.
There are still areas requiring improvement before Saturday’s matchup. Ohio State committed eight penalties for 65 yards against Maryland, and those mistakes could become considerably more damaging against an undefeated Indiana team. The Buckeyes also face a challenging road environment in Bloomington, where Indiana should be determined to protect its perfect record. Ohio State needs to maintain its offensive balance while avoiding the turnovers and penalties that can allow competitive opponents to remain within striking distance. The Buckeyes have demonstrated enough talent and consistency to win this matchup, but Indiana presents a much more demanding challenge than Maryland.
Sign Up Get $30 Premium Picks Credit + Exclusive Offers
Subscribe Now
Indiana Hoosiers Continue Finding Ways to Win
Indiana enters Saturday at 6-0 following a dramatic comeback victory over Nebraska. The Hoosiers trailed 17-6 during the fourth quarter before scoring two unanswered touchdowns to secure a 20-17 victory. That result demonstrated considerable resilience, particularly because Indiana struggled offensively for much of the afternoon. The Hoosiers have extended their impressive winning streak and remain among the nation’s undefeated programs, although Saturday’s performance exposed some concerns about their ability to control games against disciplined opponents.
Nebraska presented Indiana with significant problems by dominating possession and repeatedly extending drives. The Cornhuskers held the football for more than 39 minutes and generated 391 total yards while limiting Indiana to just 44 offensive plays. That imbalance prevented the Hoosiers from establishing their preferred offensive rhythm, forcing them to depend on explosive late-game scoring opportunities. Indiana ultimately found a way to win, but allowing another opponent to control possession so thoroughly could become dangerous against Ohio State.
The Hoosiers should benefit from returning home for one of their most important regular-season matchups. Indiana defeated Ohio State 13-10 in last season’s Big Ten Championship Game, demonstrating its ability to compete against the Buckeyes in a defensive contest. However, Ohio State has shown greater offensive consistency during the opening portion of this season, making another low-scoring victory difficult to guarantee. Indiana needs to improve its third-down defense and avoid the coverage breakdowns that nearly cost it against Nebraska. The Hoosiers have enough confidence and defensive ability to challenge Ohio State, but their margin for error will be limited.
Ohio State vs Indiana Picks and Predictions
Pick: Indiana Hoosiers +4.5
I’m taking Indiana with the 4.5 points. Ohio State deserves respect for its offensive production and four-game winning streak, but the Hoosiers have demonstrated an ability to win difficult contests without needing overwhelming offensive numbers. Indiana defeated Ohio State in last season’s Big Ten Championship Game and enters Saturday undefeated after surviving a challenging road matchup against Nebraska. The Buckeyes have been impressive, although their penalties and occasional defensive lapses create opportunities for a disciplined opponent. Playing at Memorial Stadium should also benefit Indiana, particularly in a matchup carrying considerable conference importance. Ohio State may ultimately win, but expecting the Buckeyes to create significant separation against an undefeated home team is difficult. The Hoosiers offer the better value receiving more than a field goal.
Pick: Under 49.5 Points
The Under 49.5 is the total pick. Indiana’s recent 20-17 victory against Nebraska demonstrated that the Hoosiers can become involved in physical, possession-oriented contests when opposing defenses prevent explosive plays. Ohio State has been productive offensively, but Indiana presents a more difficult defensive challenge than Maryland or Kent State. The Buckeyes should emphasize protecting the football and maintaining offensive balance, while Indiana needs to avoid allowing another opponent to dominate possession. Last season’s 13-10 conference championship meeting also demonstrates how tightly contested this matchup can become, although the current teams have their own offensive identities. A 24-21 or 27-20 result is realistic, making the Under the preferred total.
Final Picks: Indiana Hoosiers +4.5 and Under 49.5 Points
Betting on College Football?
- Bet with other College Football fans at the best sportsbooks
- Sign up today and get started with the latest college football sportsbook promos
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
New Users – Get $250 in Bonus Bets when you wager $5 for 5 days
New DraftKings Customers: Spend $5+ Get $150 in Bonuses
