Columbus Blue Jackets vs Buffalo Sabres Picks and Predictions for Thursday April 9, 2026
Sign Up Get $30 Premium Picks Credit + Exclusive Offers
Subscribe Now
The Columbus Blue Jackets travel to KeyBank Center in Buffalo, New York to take on the Buffalo Sabres on Thursday, April 9, 2026, at 7:00 PM on ESPN+. Buffalo enters this matchup as a -130 favorite on the moneyline, while Columbus sits at +110. The puck line has the Blue Jackets at +1.5 (-230) and the Sabres at -1.5 (+190), with the total set at 6.5 goals. Be sure to check out free NHL picks using our picks before placing any wagers.
Columbus Finding Mixed Results on the Road
The Blue Jackets come into this game with a 39-27-12 overall record, including a 19-16-4 mark away from home. Their recent form has been inconsistent, going 1-4 over their last five games. They recently secured a 4-3 shootout win on the road against Detroit, but before that dropped four straight contests, including losses to Winnipeg, Carolina twice, and Boston in a shootout. That stretch highlights a team that has struggled to string together consistent performances despite flashes of competitiveness.
From a statistical standpoint, Columbus averages 3.05 goals per game while allowing 3.06 goals against. They generate 29.2 shots per game and allow the same number defensively, indicating a fairly balanced pace of play. Their power play sits at 19.6% with 37 goals, while the penalty kill operates at 75.9%, allowing 51 power-play goals. The Blue Jackets have also contributed 5 shorthanded goals this season, showing some ability to create offense in all situations.
One area that stands out for Columbus is their defensive vulnerability on special teams. With a penalty kill under 76%, they have struggled to consistently shut down opposing power plays, which could be a critical factor against a team that can capitalize on those opportunities. 
Buffalo Building Momentum at Home Ice
The Sabres enter this matchup with a strong 47-23-8 record and an impressive 25-10-4 home record. Over their last five games, Buffalo has gone 3-2, recently defeating Tampa Bay 4-2. They also picked up wins over the Islanders and Seattle, though they dropped road games against Washington and Ottawa. Overall, they have been solid at home and continue to produce offensively.
Buffalo averages 3.40 goals per game while allowing 2.99 goals against, showing a clear scoring advantage compared to Columbus. They generate 28.3 shots per game and allow 29.3, suggesting they are comfortable playing in competitive, back-and-forth games. Their power play converts at 20.4% with 48 goals, while their penalty kill stands at 82.0%, allowing 39 power-play goals. Additionally, they have scored 10 shorthanded goals, which adds another layer to their offensive versatility.
A key strength for Buffalo is their special teams efficiency, particularly their penalty kill. With an 82.0% success rate, they are far more reliable defensively in those situations than Columbus, which could create a decisive edge in a game where special teams often play a major role.
Blue Jackets vs Sabres Picks and Prediction
Blue Jackets vs Sabres Pick
Pick: Sabres Moneyline (-130)
Buffalo’s home record and overall consistency make them the more reliable side in this matchup. While Columbus has shown the ability to compete, their recent four-game losing stretch prior to their last win raises concerns about sustained performance. The Sabres hold advantages in both goals per game and defensive efficiency, particularly on the penalty kill. With Buffalo also playing at home where they have been strong all season, the data supports backing the Sabres to control this matchup and secure the win.
| # | Handicapper | Profit |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Rob Vinciletti | +2,384.00 |
| 2 |  Nick Parsons | +1,985.00 |
| 3 |  Tom Macrina | +583.00 |
| 4 |  Steve Seagrave | +332.00 |
Blue Jackets vs Sabres Total Pick
Pick: Over 6.5
I’m going with the over in this matchup based on how both teams play statistically. Buffalo averages 3.40 goals per game, and Columbus allows just over three goals per contest. On the flip side, Columbus can still produce offensively, averaging just over three goals per game themselves. With both teams showing the ability to score and Columbus struggling on the penalty kill, I expect enough opportunities to push this game beyond the 6.5 total.
Final Score Prediction: Sabres 4 – Blue Jackets 3
This prediction was written before the completion of game play on Wednesday.
Betting on the NHL?
- Join Picks and Parlays premium for free and get a free $30 coupon with code FREE30
- Check out our favorite options to bet on the NHL at the best legal sportsbooks
- Start your NHL betting journey off by claiming the best sportsbook promos
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
New Users – Bet $5 Get $250 If Your Bet Wins!
New Customers: Bet $5+ Get $300 in Bonus Bets Instantly
Related posts
Baltimore Orioles vs Cleveland Guardians Picks and Predictions for Thursday, April 16, 2026
The Baltimore Orioles will be on the road Thursday night for a 6:10 PM matchup inside Progressive Field in Cleveland, OH, against the Cleveland Guardians....
