Logan Cooley Prop Picks on Goals vs. Avalanche — November 18, 2026
Logan Cooley is the kind of scorer who can make an anytime-goal ticket interesting even when his shot totals are low. He has already scored 11 times for Utah, and his ability to find open ice alongside Clayton Keller gives the Mammoth a threat on nearly every rush. Wednesday’s matchup with Colorado brings a tougher question: can Cooley turn one of those chances into a goal at a price worth the risk?
Avalanche at Mammoth: Cooley Anytime Goal Odds
Colorado visits Utah for a 10:00 p.m. ET start, with Cooley Anytime Goal Scorer at +170 among Wednesday afternoon’s prices. I would only consider the YES side at +170 or better. The bet needs Cooley to score once, whether that comes at even strength or on the power play. A good game with a couple of assists will not cash an anytime-goal ticket.
There is a reason the return is bigger than on a standard team moneyline. Cooley can create dangerous chances without putting many shots on goal, and even a strong night from him might not include a goal. The price has to compensate for that. If the available number drops to +145 or +150, I’d leave this one alone.
Cooley’s Return Gives Utah a Needed Spark
Cooley came back from an upper-body injury against Vancouver on November 16 and immediately logged 23:48, including 6:21 on the power play. He recorded an assist in the return, a positive sign for Utah after playing without one of its most creative forwards. That much ice time suggests the coaching staff still intends to give him meaningful opportunities.
The caution is that he did not record a shot on goal in that game. Playing heavy minutes is encouraging, but it doesn’t guarantee the sharpness needed to beat a goalie. I’d be much more comfortable with the anytime-goal market if Cooley is again in his usual offensive role and the Mammoth are not managing his workload after the injury.
Through 19 games, Cooley had 11 goals and 11 assists for 22 points. The 11 goals came on just 31 shots, a 35.5 percent shooting rate. That is a remarkable opening stretch, and it is also a warning not to count on him scoring once every few attempts forever. His season totals have been excellent; the long-term shooting percentage is likely to look quite different.
Where Cooley Can Create Chances Against Colorado
Utah has projected Cooley on its top forward unit with Vincent Trocheck and Keller. The power-play setup also includes Barrett Hayton and Mikhail Sergachev, giving Cooley players who can find him moving into a shooting lane. That matters because he is at his best when a pass arrives before the defense can reset, rather than when he has to beat two defenders on his own.
Colorado has been dangerous even without Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar. The Avalanche enter 12-6-3 and just beat Montreal despite those absences. Mackenzie Blackwood was the projected starter for the trip to Utah. It is a difficult matchup for a scorer returning from injury, but Colorado’s lineup changes could also give the Mammoth more possession than they might normally expect.
Utah has lost six straight, and those results have exposed problems in its own end. That can work against Cooley if the Mammoth spend too much time defending. On the other hand, a game in which Utah falls behind and needs offense could lead to more aggressive deployment for its top line. Either way, this is a player who needs quality chances, not simply more shifts.
A Big Goal Total Doesn’t Make This a Safe Bet
Cooley’s goal total has run well ahead of his shot volume. Expected-goals estimates put his individual chances closer to roughly six goals than eleven, even allowing for differences in how opportunities are measured. That doesn’t mean the early goals were luck. It means the finishes have been exceptional, and it would be unwise to expect every difficult look to keep finding the net.
The positive angle is his first-line and power-play position. If Utah gets several man advantages or Cooley finds room on the weak side, one clean chance may be enough. The negative angle is just as real: his shotless return and Colorado’s overall defensive quality. For me, that combination calls for a small, speculative plus-money play, not an aggressive stake.
Best Bet: Logan Cooley Anytime Goal Scorer (+170 or Better)
My lean is Cooley to score a goal at +170 or better. He has the finishing touch and the offensive role to get there, especially with Keller creating chances around him. But I would pass at +150 or shorter and would not take the bet if his lineup position or ice time looks limited. That is the line between an interesting price and an unnecessary gamble.
Cooley’s 11 goals show his upside, while the 31 shots and recent injury explain the volatility. A goal could come from a rush, a rebound or a power-play sequence; none is guaranteed. Keep this as a small-stake selection and be comfortable with the chance that Utah gets offense from somebody else. For the full slate, see our NHL predictions.
Never Tried Picks and Parlays? Now Is Your Chance
- Get your first daily picks package for ONLY $1 using coupon code BUCK
- If the pick loses, we credit your account with 3 Flex Picks
- If the pick wins, we still give you 1 Flex Pick on the house
- Win or lose, you walk away ahead. One dollar. No catch.
Get Up to $1,000 Back in Bonus Bets Over Your First 10 Days
New Users - Get $200 in Bonus Bets when you wager $5 for 4 days
Bet $5, Get $200 + 3 Months of NBA League Pass

