New York Rangers vs Ottawa Senators Picks and Predictions for Thursday December 4 2025
Use Code PPWC
The New York Rangers head to the Canadian Tire Centre on Thursday night looking to build off their thrilling overtime win against Dallas, while the Ottawa Senators aim to continue their solid home play and stabilize after a mixed stretch of performances. With New York at 14-12-2 and Ottawa at 13-9-4, both teams sit in the same tier of the NHL standings—dangerous, inconsistent, and capable of winning (or losing) any given night. Before breaking down the edges in this matchup, make sure to check out the rest of today’s free NHL picks for more betting insight.
New York Rangers – Team Form, Goaltending & Betting Profile
The Rangers enter this matchup on a positive note after a 3–2 overtime win over Dallas, rebounding from their 4–1 loss to Tampa Bay. This recent run has shown a pattern—when they get timely scoring and adequate defensive structure, they can beat quality opponents. Their 14-12-2 overall record and outstanding 11-4-1 road mark highlight a team that plays some of its best hockey away from Madison Square Garden.
Offensively, the Rangers are producing 2.64 goals per game, led by Artemi Panarin’s 28 points (8G, 20A). Mika Zibanejad leads the team with 9 goals, though New York could certainly use a bit more finishing from its top six. Defensively, the Rangers allow 2.61 goals per game, which aligns closely with their expected value and speaks to their structured play at 5-on-5.
The biggest stabilizer remains Igor Shesterkin, who owns an impressive 2.45 GAA and .912 save percentage across 22 appearances. With Jonathan Quick on IR until December 7, the Rangers will continue riding Shesterkin heavily, and that actually provides consistency going into this matchup. Their penalty kill at 81.3% is solid, and New York’s discipline (207 penalty minutes—on the lower side league-wide) keeps games manageable.
Sign Up Get $30 Premium Picks Credit + Exclusive Offers
Subscribe Now
Injuries remain a mild concern as defenseman Adam Fox (IR-LT) is still out until late December, leaving a noticeable gap in transition and power play orchestration. Still, this team has shown resilience during his absence.
Ottawa Senators – Team Form, Home Ice Dependability & Betting Outlook
Ottawa snapped its mini-slide with a 5–2 road win over Montreal, a much-needed bounce-back after losses to Dallas and St. Louis. The Senators sit at 13-9-4, including a strong 6-3-2 home record, where they generally show better defensive stability and more consistent offensive pressure.
The Senators score 3.12 goals per game, powered by Tim Stützle’s 24 points (11G, 13A) and Shane Pinto’s team-leading 12 goals. They don’t generate a huge volume of shots (26.2 per game), but they remain opportunistic and efficient—especially at home.
Defensively, Ottawa allows 3.31 goals per game, which is a touch high, but their 25.4 shots allowed per game is one of the lower marks in the NHL, indicating structural soundness that sometimes gets undone by goaltending volatility. Speaking of goaltending, it’s been a roller coaster. Linus Ullmark has a 3.05 GAA and an .876 save percentage, which is far below his usual standards. Backup Leevi Meriläinen has also struggled (.874 SV%).
If Ullmark returns to form, Ottawa becomes significantly more dangerous. If he doesn’t, they can get exposed even in tightly structured games.
With Thomas Chabot nearing return (IR until Dec 4), the Senators could regain a major defensive contributor, which would be a meaningful boost ahead of this matchup.
New York Rangers vs Ottawa Senators – Statistical Matchup Breakdown
Here are the key statistical edges heading into this matchup:
Offense
- Senators: 3.12 GF/G
- Rangers: 2.64 GF/G Edge: Ottawa
Defense
- Rangers: 2.61 GA/G
- Senators: 3.31 GA/G Edge: New York
Special Teams
- Power Play: Ottawa 21.3% vs NYR 19.7%
- Penalty Kill: Rangers 81.3% vs Ottawa 68.4%
Combined special teams edge heavily favors the Rangers—particularly because Ottawa’s penalty kill is struggling badly (68.4%).
Goaltending
- Shesterkin: 2.45 GAA / .912 SV%
- Ullmark: 3.05 GAA / .876 SV% Clear edge: New York
Recent Form
- Rangers: 4–1 in their last 5
- Senators: 2–3 in their last 5
New York is trending upward, while Ottawa has been up and down.
Picks and Predictions
After walking through the numbers, I’m siding with the New York Rangers +130 on the moneyline. Getting Shesterkin as an underdog is something I’m always going to give serious consideration to—and given Ottawa’s recent defensive lapses, inconsistent goaltending, and poor penalty kill, this is a spot where I trust New York’s structure and road performance more.
New York’s 11-4-1 road record combined with Shesterkin’s efficiency makes them a strong value play. Ottawa absolutely can score, but their defensive reliability has wavered, and they haven’t shown the same ability to grind out tight games the way New York has over the past couple of weeks.
On the total, I lean Under 5.5 (-110). The Rangers typically dictate slower-paced, defensive-minded games on the road, and Shesterkin has been excellent. Ottawa allows few shots per game, which should help suppress scoring on both sides. Unless this becomes a special teams battle, the under feels like the sharper angle. Betting on sports and on the Rangers is easy, but even easier if you use the best sportsbooks. Make sure you know about how the fans are looking on prediction markets for the Senators with the Novig promo code. Make sure when you place your bet on Rangers vs Senators you are using the BetMGM bonus code.
My Final Picks:
- New York Rangers ML (+130)
- Under 5.5 Goals (-110)
Projected Final Score:
Rangers 3 – Senators 2
Never Tried Picks and Parlays? Now Is Your Chance
- Get your first daily picks package for ONLY $1 using coupon code BUCK
- If the pick loses, we credit your account with 3 Flex Picks
- If the pick wins, we still give you 1 Flex Pick on the house
- Win or lose, you walk away ahead. One dollar. No catch.
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
New Users – Bet $5 Get $200 in Bet Reset Tokens for 5 Days
New DraftKings Customers: Spend $5+ Get $200 in Bonuses Instantly!
