This is the most interesting regression play of the entire Saturday card, but there is enough conflicting evidence to keep it on the free card.
Tampa Bay finished with an extraordinary +14.61 Luck Rating, the highest in baseball. New York was only +0.95. That produces approximately a 13.7-game Luck Gap toward the Yankees. At a full-season sample size, that's enormous.
There is also value in getting New York as an underdog. Our official outlaw line opened around Yankees +114/Rays -134, and the market has remained in that general neighborhood rather than producing a major move against New York.
The concern is the pitching matchup. Drew Rasmussen's report card is outstanding: 16-5 with a 2.67 ERA and 0.91 WHIP. He has been especially effective against New York, posting a 1.81 ERA and 0.86 WHIP across 11 career appearances. In his most recent start at Yankee Stadium, he carried a no-hitter into the seventh and struck out 11.
Gerrit Cole counters with a 3.61 ERA for the season, but his Rays-specific report card is considerably better: a 2.50 ERA in three starts against Tampa Bay this year. He also brings a strong postseason résumé.
New York enters on a four-game winning streak and scored nine runs in each of its two Wild Card victories.
The enormous Luck Gap makes +115 attractive enough for a free play, but Rasmussen keeps it on the free card.
Play Yankees +110 or better.